This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through links. I will only recommend products that I have personally used or thoroughly reviewed! Learn more on my Privacy Policy page.
Some stones in a scary game are better left unturned
Key Takeaways
- Lore Richness: The game excels in weaving deep Dead by Daylight lore into its narrative, appealing especially to longtime fans.
- Gameplay Innovations: Introduces features like the “Cutting Room Floor” for enhanced interactivity and replayability, enriching the gaming experience.
- Cinematic Quality: Supermassive Games’ trademark cinematic style elevates the game’s atmospheric and visual appeal, contributing to a compelling horror experience.
- Gameplay Feedback: Receives mixed reviews regarding interactivity and pacing, with some criticism focusing on the integration of quick-time events and accessibility for new players.
Overview

Dead by Daylight, the well-known multiplayer horror game where survivors are put against infamous killers, has taken its frights to a new level with The Casting of Frank Stone.
This latest expansion, developed in collaboration with Supermassive Games and Behaviour Interactive Inc., marks the game’s ambitious leap into single-player, interactive narrative horror.
Released on September 3, 2024, on Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5, and Windows, this scary game invites you into an insidious story set in the eerie town of Cedar Hills, A town shaped by the dark legacy of Frank Stone.
If you want to read another single-player scary game recently released that I covered, click here.
With that being said, after some extensive research on one the cool indie horror games so far, I will share all I could find on the Casting of Frank Stone with you. So let’s explore “Dead By Daylight’s New Scary Game.”
The Game’s Premise

The story is rooted in Cedar Hills, a place haunted by the violent past of Frank Stone, whose deeds have left traumatic marks on its residents and even reality itself. You navigate a story brimming with cosmic horrors and emotional depths.
Every choice you make carves out a new path through the game’s dark and twisted web-like story and supports the gameplay.
Gameplay Features

The Casting of Frank Stone introduces several groundbreaking features for the Dead by Daylight game, increasing the engagement levels. Key among these is the “Cutting Room Floor,” a feature that allows you to revisit and alter crucial decisions without restarting the game.
This mechanic provides 185 possible branches and 16 potential endings, ensuring a variety of outcomes where every choice makes an impact in this scary game (Dead by Daylight) (Xbox Wire).
Such decision based features highlights the importance of choice. Supermassive Games, known for their interactive-cinematic titles like Until Dawn and The Dark Pictures Anthology, brought their signature style to Dead by Daylight.
The game’s visuals and lore depth offers a cinematic experience that keeps you on the edge of their seats (Press room).
Twitch Integration

Adding a social dimension to the gameplay, the expansion includes “Twitch integration,” where viewers can influence decisions in real-time during streams. This feature caters to both the streamer and their audience, making each playthrough of this scary game a community engaging experience (Xbox Wire).
Exploring New Grounds

Besides the main narrative arc, you can explore various side stories and secrets scattered throughout Cedar Hills. Each decision not only influences the immediate scenario but also unfolds potential subplots that flesh out the overarching mystery of Frank Stone (Dead by Daylight).
Deluxe Edition and Rewards

The deluxe edition of this scary game offers immediate access to the Cutting Room Floor, exclusive costumes, and special rewards within Dead by Daylight, providing gamers with additional content to enhance their gaming experience (The Casting of Frank Stone).
One such content is Plunderer’s Instinct, allowing you to hunt for collectables shrouded in darkness. Such content is gameplay Dead by Daylight will benefit from as it helps to boast replayability for lore and other story routes to tread.
Community Feedback

The Casting of Frank Stone also fosters a robust community interaction, with forums and social media buzzing with discussions and theories about the game’s unfolding mysteries. The engagement extends beyond the game, as fans dissect every twist and turn of the storyline (Dead by Daylight).
Leading up to the release, the game stirred considerable buzz within the Dead by Daylight community. Even upon its release, there’s still talk and varying reactions from fans and critics alike, exploring both the acclaim and the critiques that have surfaced.
Positive Feedback
Fans of Dead by Daylight have expressed excitement over the game’s deep integration of lore and its dual-timeline narrative, which keeps the mystery alive and engaging from start to finish.
Many appreciate the easter eggs and hints tied to the broader Dead by Daylight universe, enhancing the game’s appeal for long-time fans.
Fans felt positive about these easter eggs, as one fan mentioned on X,
“No joke there’s a Dead By Daylight reference or easter egg every 5 steps you take in Casting of Frank Stone. Some may find this annoying, but personally I find it very charming.”
While another wrote on Steam,
“Story is really good, twists that i did not expect, really enjoyed what went on & can’t wait to explore other choices. Some new mechanics not seen in previous titles from these devs are enjoyable & well done.”
The game’s cinematic quality and atmosphere have been particularly praised, maintaining the high standards expected from a collaboration with Supermassive Games (PCGamesN).
Critiques and Challenges
However, not all feedback has been glowing. Some players have pointed out a lack of interactivity, which could detract from the engagement levels expected from a game tied so closely to an action-driven franchise like Dead by Daylight.
A fan called out on Steam,
“The story didn’t seem to make a lot of sense and so our decisions felt less impactful overall.”
The game’s conclusion and some narrative decisions have been described as potentially confusing for those not deeply familiar with the Dead by Daylight lore, which could alienate new players or casual fans (PCGamesN) (The Gaming Watcher).
Critics have also noted that while the game introduces new features like the Cutting Room Floor, which allows for replayability of key scenes, it sometimes struggles with pacing and could benefit from more polished gameplay mechanics.
The integration of quick-time events has received mixed reviews, with some finding them a thrilling addition, while others felt they disrupted the narrative flow (PCGamesN).
Community Discussions

On platforms like Steam, discussions have revolved around technical aspects and rewards linked to the game. Some players have experienced issues with claiming their rewards, leading to frustration despite the support available. This aspect seems to be a minor hiccup in an otherwise smooth launch (Steam Community).
As an indie horror, The Casting of Frank Stone marks a bold expansion of the Dead by Daylight universe, attempting to blend cinematic storytelling with gameplay Dead by Daylight is known for.
While it achieves many of its ambitious goals, the feedback from the community highlights areas for improvement, particularly in making the game more accessible to newcomers and smoothing out gameplay elements to enhance the overall experience
Closing Thoughts

The Casting of Frank Stone is a significant expansion of the Dead by Daylight universe. It invites both veterans and newcomers to dive into its cinematic narrative and newly added gameplay.
This release is one of the many cool indie horror games that dare explore more of its world. As you unravel the mysteries of Cedar Hills, you contribute to a story that is continuously shaped by your or the community’s collective choices.
This game created, like a Frankenstein monster, a story that blends interactive storytelling with horror to make an unforgettable experience.
If you’re not into cinematic gameplay or choice based stories, you might not enjoy this game. However, for fans eager to step into the world of Cedar Hills and face the legacy of Frank Stone. this game is for you.
So, what did you think of the Casting of Frank Stone? How did you feel narrative style of the game?

Nero lives in the United States, delving into indie horror to mainstream games. Armed with a psych degree and a passion for storytelling, he wrote stories and essays published online and in museum catalogs. Besides writing, he also likes sketching and tuning into rock music. Catch his latest posts or follow him across social media.